Friday, October 3, 2008

Dez's Favorite 100 Rock/Pop Records, #'s 15-11

This is an eclectic batch...

15. Duran Duran – Rio, 1982
#15 defines a certain period of the 80’s…glitzy, superficial, dangerous, fun, excessive. But as with much of Duran Duran’s material, what on the surface may seem slight synthesizer pop, there is an interesting undercurrent of unease and melancholy. These guys were much better musicians than their detractors give them credit for (especially bassist John Taylor and guitarist Andy Taylor), and Rio is their seminal release. It remains as glitzy and as listenable today as it was when it was released. The title track and “Hungry Like the Wolf” are both classic 80’s glam singles, accompanied by iconic music videos. But the album tracks are just as interesting, such as the brooding Roxy Music-ish “The Chauffeur” and “Lonely In Your Nightmare.” The highlight is “Save a Prayer,” which captures what is great about Duran Duran and also the essence of 80’s excess culture, it is both glamorous and wistful, and full of sweet regret. It is easy to make glamorous pop singles about the wild night on the town, but harder to write them about the morning after. DD simultaneously captures the seductive hedonism of 80’s excess and the consequences only fully understood on the day after. Even further, the song is ambiguous enough to where the listener is not sure whether Simon le Bon, even knowing the consequences, would have done anything differently.


ABOVE: Rio's iconic album cover

14. Pete Yorn – Musicforthemorningafter, 2001
Just when I thought I had discovered all the great music there was to discover, I came across this guy’s nearly perfect debut. Part Springsteen and part New Order, Yorn’s songwriting arrived almost fully formed. Infectious singles “Strange Condition” and “Life on a Chain” got lots of deserved play on college radio, but the rest of the record is just as good. There is not a bad song here. Yorn is a guitar player, but he was also a drummer, and his understanding of rhythm shows. What is great about this record is that as good as it is all the way through, he saves the most effective songs for the end with the triple shot of “On Your Side,” “Sleep Better” and “EZ”. He stumbled on his sophomore outing, but his third record was outstanding as well. Can't wait to hear more.

13. Peter Gabriel – Peter Gabriel (aka 'I', ‘car’), 1977
Gabriel’s solo debut is bursting with the joy of freedom. He had just shocked much of the rock world by suddenly leaving Genesis just as they were peaking at the forefront of the prog rock genre. He leaves behind the sprawling 10 minute prog epics and delivers a set of relatively concise tunes in a variety of styles, things that he had been wanting to try but could not within the constraints of Genesis. It is the sound of a man who is bursting with talent and ideas finally let loose to follow any avenue he found interesting. Not all of it works (like the odd barbershop “Excuse Me”), but it is thrilling to hear him try. “Solsbury Hill” is Gabriel’s personal declaration of independence from his old band, and gives an explanation of why he had to leave. “Modern Love” and “Slowburn” are assured rockers, while the odd “Moribund the Burgermeister” and “Down the Dolce Vita” show that he has not completely turned his back on art rock. As the notes of the beautiful closer “Here Comes the Flood” fade, one is left with anticipation for what Gabriel’s solo career would deliver in the future. He didn’t disappoint.

12. Big Star - #1 Record, 1972
Critic Jason Ankeny describes Big Star as "the quintessential American power pop band and one of the most mythic and influential cult acts in all of rock & roll.” If you think #1 Record is a rather presumptuous title for a debut, they back it up with the music. Unfortunately, nobody was listening at the time. But decades later people started to listen. Big Star is often referred to as “the best band you’ve never heard of.” If this list inspires its readers to pick up a couple of records they have never heard before, please let this be one of them. In a just universe, Big Star would be standing next to the Rolling Stones, Beatles and Who as one of the greatest bands ever. Instead, this Memphis unit was torn apart by self-doubt, fragile personalities, record label indifference, and bum circumstance. But listen to the promise on this record, the shimmering pop brilliance in Alex Chilton and Chris Bell’s songs grabs you immediately. Bell’s “Feel” and “In the Street” rock out, while Chilton’s “Ballad of El Goodo” and “Thirteen” capture adolescence perfectly (“Tell your Dad to get off my back / Tell him what we said about ‘Paint It Black’”) They combine the best of The Kinks, Who, Byrds and Beatles in their sound, and create something all their own. In turn, even if they did not have commercial success, many notable musicians cite them as big influences, such as REM. Go get this now. In one of the best deals in music, it is available in combination with the almost as great follow-up Radio City on a single disc.

11. Uncle Tupelo – No Depression, 1990
This is ground zero for the modern resurgence of country-rock, alt-country...or whatever you want to call it. Tupelo approached it from a punk/county/folk angle, and their groundbreaking and hugely influential debut is startling in its raw energy and emotion. By successfully pulling off the unlikely marriage between punk rock and country music, they inspired an entire subgenre in their wake. This record is so influential that it inspired the name of the ‘No Depression’ alt-country periodical and lent its name as an alternate moniker for the entire musical movement. (“No Depression” the song is a cover of the A.P. Carter classic). Out of the duo of Jeff Tweedy and Jay Farrar, it is Tweedy who would later emerge in his next band Wilco as a fan and critical darling on the alt-circuit; but back then, this was Farrar’s show. His stop/start brutal everyman rockers like “Factory Belt” and “Graveyard Shift” still thrill, while new classic country dirges like “Whiskey Bottle” and “Life Worth Livin’” stand up with the best barroom-at-2 a.m.-tear-in-my-beer weepers of yore. Equal parts Minutemen and Merle Haggard, they deftly bring these disparate influences together and create this grim masterpiece of Midwestern angst that only grows in stature with each passing year.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Love the Pete Yorn pic. He's great.

JMW said...

Love Big Star, love Uncle Tupelo, love Peter Gabriel.

You introduced me to the Pete Yorn, and I really like it. That's still a very high ranking for it, but I shouldn't gripe, since this is at least half about personal favorites.

Let me gripe about Duran Duran instead. #15?? You make fun of me for being so '90s-dependent, but your relationship to the 80s is at least as troubling. I like Duran Duran, but #15???

Johannes said...

I wouldn't balk at any of these. I own #1 Record, but never really got into it that much. I tried, but it never struck me as compelling ever. I also am not nearly as into Duran Duran as you, but you made me question my dismissal of The Cure, so who knows. Yorn is a good call, though, i'm surprised to see it this high up. I mean, we're right up there, aren't we. We're on the desert island. I'm impressed and glad to see No Depression up here, I didn't think you were that into The Tup. "Life Worth Livin" - heck yes. That album reminds me vividly of College, you guys, Todd, Prassel, my old hairline. Ahh.

ANCIANT said...

Prassel Prassel

Johannes said...

Heh heh. I remember that. I love that.

Dezmond said...

JMW, yes, #15 for Duran Duran. I will admit I am partial to DD since I was a fan during their heyday, and since then I have steadfastly defended them. It has been nice to see that they have become more and more appreciated the more time passes. RIO is so definitive, it is so representative of its time. But beyond that, it is still so listenable today. Not that I depend on it, but I could cite some other critical sources. The All-Music Guide gives RIO a ***** rating, which is their highest. Likewise, MusicHound Guide gives RIO a rating of five bones, also their highest rating, calling it "one of the defining records of the early 80's". In the popular resource "1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die", RIO is likewise honored, where it is written that "RIO-era Duran Duran were matchless in their ability to craft perfect pop that defined a decade." #15 for RIO? Hells yeah.

Plus, 80's music is objectively better than 90's music. And this list is more than "at least half about personal favorites", that's all that it is. If I were writing a scholarly article on the best and most influential records ever, it would look very different than it does.

Yes, Johannes, we are now on the beach of that desert island. (Although, I would probably pick some good compilations if we had to play the desert island game). You didn't know I was that into Tupelo!?! I've been a Tupelo fanatic for a long time. Although, not while we were in college. It was right after college that I really got into them. Recall that STILL FEEL GONE appeared earlier on this list. Dave and I still cover several Tupelo gems when we play.

JMW said...

Dez, I actually meant to come back yesterday and retract my comment about Duran Duran. I agree -- these lists are about what we like most. I think it's cool that you have DD so high. I'm sure I'll have more than one in my top 10 (eight? nine?) that you think are way out of place "objectively." So. As you were...

Dezmond said...

It's all cool. But please continue to criticize and comment if you disagree with my enthusiasm for a certain record (or its placement). One of the best things about these lists are the debates that they inspire. Because these are "favorites," we should also be able to defend their value as well. I did not mean to fall back on the "don't criticize me, these are just my favorites" card. You know I think that's a bullshit stance. So please, critique away.

pockyjack said...

"It has been nice to see that they have become more and more appreciated the more time passes"

Wait . . what?

Dezmond said...

You heard me. When they were at their peak of popularity, they were dismissed critically. Since that time, their music from that period has grown in stature. Again, see the citations on RIO above.