Monday, August 6, 2012

Song #1

Title: "Tunnel of Love" or "Tunnel of Love" (live)
Artist: Dire Straits
Albums: Original studio version from Making Movies, 1980. Live version from Alchemy, 1984.
Written By: Mark Knopfler

I've gone back and forth over the years between preferring the epic live version of this tune from Alchemy or the relatively streamlined 8-minute studio rendition. So, instead of picking one or the other (currently, I probably prefer the studio version), I decided to list them both. Same song.

Since I picked this as my favorite song, I naturally feel that it has it all. Fantastic lyrics (using the amusement park backdrop as metaphor for a nostalgic look back at youth), stellar playing from the band, soaring guitar solos from Knopfler, and it features what I have always felt was a strength of Dire Straits, especially in the live arena, which is dramatic use of dynamics. The song roars along as a rock song, then Knopfler and co. bring it down to a whisper, then build it up to a crescendo higher than before. That use of dynamics is all over Alchemy, and it was a frequent tool used throughout the life of Dire Straits. Not surprisingly, this was the finale of their main sets for many years.

BELOW: Studio version.


BELOW: Unfortunately I couldn't find a clip of the Alchemy version that was of sufficient quality. But, check this live clip from London in '85, it is indicative of how Dire Straits would expand a tune from its studio origins, and it approximates the expanded Alchemy version.

Sunday, August 5, 2012

Song #2

Title: "Bluebird"
Artist: Buffalo Springfield
Album: Buffalo Springfield Again, 1967
Written By: Stephen Stills

Neil Young may have been the wild card that made Buffalo Springfield such a fascinating band, and Richie Furay may have had the sweetest voice and the most direct line to the country veins they were mining, but it was always Stephen Stills' band. Stills was responsible for their one hit ("For What Its Worth"), their greatest folk-rock fusion ("Rock and Roll Woman"), and their greatest song (this one). I have already written at length about the enigma of Stephen Stills. Few artist had his all around talent and potential, and then the extremely frustrating career he's had, with occasional peaks amidst disappointing mediocrity and crap. How his once glorious vocal, writing and guitar skills all have been in free fall for decades. But look to this song, and this is what Stills should be celebrated for. It is a stunning blend of rock, folk and country elements and then the glorious bluegrass coda. Neil Young plays some razor sharp electric guitar, but it is Stills on acoustic who delivers my favorite guitar solo ever, starting at about 2:15.

Friday, August 3, 2012

Song #3

Title: "Bad" (live)
Artist: U2
Album: Wide Awake in America EP, 1985. Original version from The Unforgettable Fire, 1984
Written By: U2

This one is a frequent highlight in their live set to this day, and it is easy to hear why. Starting off ethereal and crescendoing to an emotional roar and then back again, it is a song infused with drama. The studio version is great, but again, it is a live version that takes it to new heights for me. This Unforgettable Fire period is Bono's peak as a vocalist, I think. Up to this point he was still finding his voice (and learning to sing, frankly), and he has lost a bit of his range and capacity over time ever since. Also, this is textbook Edge on guitar, why he is less a great player and more a brilliant sound architect and innovator.



Bonus Clip: Here's the original studio version for comparison purposes. As usual, ignore the cheesy visuals that the YouTube poster added.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Song #4

Title: "Incident on 57th Street"
Artist: Bruce Springsteen
Album: The Wild, The Innocent & the E Street Shuffle, 1973
Written By: Bruce Springsteen

As much as I have loved Springsteen's music over the years, you'd think I'd have more than one of his songs in the 24. Suffice it to say that in my expanded Top 200 he is very well represented. This early, pre-Born To Run period is my favorite Springsteen era. He was loose, he was hungry. As great as the E Street Band is (and they are one of the great rock bands), I really love this earliest line-up. Clarence Clemons, Danny Federici and Garry Talent were there from the beginning, but two crucial differences here are David Sancious on piano/electric piano and Vinny "Mad Dog" Lopez on drums. Max Weinberg is a great drummer (and has more technique than Lopez), but Lopez could swing in a way that Max never has.

Anyway, this song (this whole album, really, which is my favorite of his) is the peak of his romanticized Jersey tales, before the more grand escapism and ambition of Born To Run, and way before any sort of working class consciousness of Darkness on the Edge of Town and beyond. Honestly, it is what he really knew vs. trying to make the grander statements of the later years.

This was also when he wrote songs of more epic structure and length, before the Darkness-era streamlining that has continued to this day. (The big difference is that around Darkness he stopped writing songs on the piano and started writing them on the guitar, and you can tell the difference). I love the dynamics, the exuberance, the quirky lyrics, and the great guitar solo (from Bruce himself) at the climax of the song. This is one of the favorites for many Bruce diehards, but it is not very familiar to the masses.

BELOW: I was able to find about 30 different live versions of this song on YouTube, but nobody bothered to post the studio version, which is my actual pick. But this spirited live version from 1980 is a close approximation to the original, although I still do prefer the original. It being 1980, it does not feature Lopez or Sancious. Ignore the rather random images with this clip.


BELOW: Bonus clip. This is a stark, lovely version of the song from '75. Here Bruce is on the piano, accompanied only by the haunting violin of Suki Lahav.

Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Song #5

Title: "Celluloid Heroes" (live)
Artist: The Kinks
Album: One For the Road, 1980. Original studio version from Everybody's in Showbiz, 1972.
Written By: Ray Davies

I almost had to love this one. A fantastic rock song by one of the greatest bands ever that is a nostalgic look at movies. This is another pick where the live version far outpaces the original studio version, even though the studio version is quite great. But this live version is several steps higher. First of all, that opening guitar solo by Dave Davies...man! Much like the solo I talked about in the live version of "Wild West End" below, it is not particularly technical or complex, but it is just perfect in its melodicism, pacing, feel. Dave Davies is one of the best on the instrument. And brother Ray, meanwhile, would compete for rock's greatest songwriter.



BELOW: Bonus clip. Here's the original version. Not as brilliant, but still great.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Song #6

Title: "Overkill"
Artist: Men At Work
Album: Cargo, 1983
Written By: Colin Hay

Longtime friends and associates know of my obsession with Men at Work. No surprise that they would have a tune on this list somewhere. "Down Under" may be a little more famous and more fun, but "Overkill" is the better song. Colin Hay is my favorite rock vocalist, and this song really shows the guy's amazing range, which has remained, for the most part, intact. And lets not overlook the other members of the band. Greg Ham's (RIP, earlier this year) saxes are front and center, and Ron Strykert is a fantastic, melodic, underappreciated guitarist. Colin Hay tours both with a band and solo acoustic these days, and I would suggest catching him if you can. Not only is the music outstanding, but he is very engaging and a funny storyteller when onstage. I saw him in a small club in Austin awhile back, and he could not have been a cooler guy. He hung out after the show, signed autographs, shook hands and told stories. What a great dude.



Bonus clip: Here is the famous episode of "Scrubs" where Colin shows up and plays "Overkill" solo acoustic. It has been edited together from the episode so the song plays all the way through. Very funny.

Monday, July 30, 2012

Song #7

Title: "Wild West End" (live)
Artist: Dire Straits
Album: Live version available on bootlegs of the August 17, 1985 show in Houston, Texas. Original studio version from Dire Straits, 1978.
Written By: Mark Knopfler

This is a rather unique pick for my list, because this version was never officially released, although it is widely available on a popular bootleg. It was bootlegged so much because the show was broadcast nationally on the radio, so lots of tapes were made. Unlike my previous pick, where the studio version could have stood in at the same spot for the live version I officially picked, that is not so in this case. While I do love the studio version of this song, the live version that I picked takes it to an entirely different level. Is it within the rules for me to pick a bootleg for my list? Sure, I don't see why not. These are the 24 songs, regardless of format or availability.

I've discussed this particular song before, but a refresher. I was present at the creation of this version you can listen to below, as it is from the first concert that I ever attended. Summer night in Houston at the no longer existing Southern Star Amphitheater behind the no longer existing Astroworld. Perfect night, with the amusement park as the backdrop. You can hear the whole show (and many, many other legendary shows from many different artists at the website Wolfgang's Vault. May I also suggest the '78 Springsteen show that will absolutely knock your socks off.)

The track is a beautiful, fairly faithful rendition of the original (with Knopfler playing his national steel guitar) until about 6:25 in where one of the most gorgeous guitar solos ever blows the doors down. Mark Knopfler is my favorite guitarist, but this solo is actually played by the second Dire Straits guitarist at the time, Jack Sonni. Knopfler gave Sonni a solo or two per night on the Brothers in Arms tour, and the dude certainly made the most of this one! It is not particularly complicated or technically challenging, but it is just so right and soars to great heights. What a great first concert, eh?

BELOW: Here is the version that makes #7 on my list, available at Wolfgang's Vault:

Listen to more Dire Straits at Wolfgang's Vault.

BELOW: Bonus clip. Here's the original studio version, which is a gorgeous song on its own.